Common Surgical Errors That Lead to Medical Malpractice Lawsuits
Nov. 19, 2026
Every surgery carries some risk, and most patients understand that when they sign the consent forms. What they don't expect is a preventable mistake: an operation on the wrong knee, a sponge left behind, or a nicked bowel that nobody catches until sepsis sets in.
As a Seattle surgical errors lawyer, I talk with patients and families who are trying to figure out whether what happened to them was a known complication or negligence. The answer usually depends on the specific facts, and getting the details right early makes a real difference.
Wrong-Site, Wrong-Patient, and Wrong-Procedure
These errors are rare, but they are among the clearest cases of negligence. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality lists wrong-site surgery among the serious reportable events, often called "never events", because they should not happen when a surgical team follows basic safety checks. Since February 2009, Medicare has not paid for costs associated with wrong-site surgeries.
These mistakes usually come from breakdowns in pre-surgery verification. Typical examples are a surgical site that was never marked, a skipped "time-out" before the first incision, or a scheduling error that went unnoticed. In these cases, I focus on who was responsible for each verification step and where the process failed.
Surgical Instruments and Sponges Left Inside the Body
Leaving a foreign object inside a patient after surgery is another serious reportable event. Sponges, clamps, needles, and broken instrument tips can cause infections, bowel obstructions, chronic pain, and the need for more surgery. Symptoms sometimes don't appear for months.
Washington law treats these cases differently from most malpractice claims. Under RCW 4.16.350, the filing deadline is paused when a foreign body is left in a patient without a therapeutic or diagnostic purpose, and it stays paused until the patient actually learns of it. The patient then has one year from that date to file. One year passes quickly, so if an imaging study shows a retained object, I recommend talking to a lawyer right away.
Anesthesia Errors
Anesthesia mistakes include giving the wrong dose, missing a patient's allergy or medication interaction, intubating incorrectly, and failing to monitor oxygen levels and vital signs during the procedure. The results can range from awareness during surgery to brain injury or death.
These cases often turn on the monitoring records. In an anesthesia claim, one of the first things I request is the electronic anesthesia record, which logs readings minute by minute. Gaps in that record, or readings that went unaddressed, often tell the story.
Organ, Nerve, and Blood Vessel Damage During Surgery
Damage to nearby structures is one of the most common sources of surgical malpractice claims. Examples include a bile duct cut during gallbladder removal, a perforated bowel during laparoscopic surgery, a nerve injured during a joint replacement, and a nicked artery during a routine abdominal procedure.
Not every one of these injuries is malpractice. Some are known risks that can happen even with careful technique. The key questions are whether the surgeon correctly identified the anatomy before cutting and whether the technique matched what a careful surgeon would have used. Those questions require review by a qualified medical reviewer, and I have that review done early.
Failure to Spot Complications After Surgery
In my experience, the strongest case often isn't about the surgery itself. It's about what happened afterward. A bowel perforation may be a recognized risk, but if the patient's fever, rising heart rate, and abdominal pain were documented for two days before anyone ordered a CT scan, the delayed response may be the negligence. Post-operative infections, internal bleeding, and blood clots fall into the same category. Nursing notes, vital-sign charts, and call logs are often the most important evidence in these cases.
Surgery Without Informed Consent
Washington treats lack of informed consent as a separate basis for a claim. A surgeon must explain the material risks of a procedure and the reasonable alternatives. If you weren't told about a significant risk, that risk happened, and a reasonable patient would have chosen differently with that information, you may have a claim even if the surgery itself was performed correctly. I also look closely at whether the surgeon who actually operated was the one you consented to, which matters at teaching hospitals where residents often perform parts of the procedure.
What You Must Prove in a Washington Surgical Malpractice Case
Under RCW 7.70.040, you must show that the provider failed to use the care, skill, and learning expected of a reasonably prudent health care provider in the same profession or class, and that this failure was a proximate cause of your injury.
In practice, that usually means a medical professional has to testify about the standard of care and how it was breached. Retained-object cases can be an exception, because a sponge left inside a patient may speak for itself. Washington also has no cap on noneconomic damages in malpractice cases, so compensation for pain, disability, and lost quality of life isn't limited by a set dollar figure.
Deadlines for Filing a Surgical Error Claim in Washington
Generally, a claim must be filed within three years of the act or omission, or within one year of when you discovered or reasonably should have discovered the injury and its cause, whichever is later.
The statute still lists an eight-year outer limit, but in Bennett v. United States, the Washington Supreme Court ruled in 2023 that the eight-year statute of repose violated the privileges and immunities clause of the state constitution. That ruling matters for patients whose injuries weren't found until years later. Even so, I never rely on the outer limits. The safest approach is to act within the three-year window whenever possible.
Steps to Take If You Suspect a Surgical Error
Request your complete records. Ask for operative reports, anesthesia records, nursing notes, and imaging, not just discharge summaries.
Get follow-up care from a different provider if you can. A new surgeon or specialist can document your condition independently.
Keep a written timeline. Note your symptoms, who you spoke with, and what you were told.
Don't count on the hospital's internal review. Washington requires facilities to report certain adverse events to the Department of Health, but those reports and the hospital's internal analysis are generally confidential. Your case will be built on your own records and independent medical review.
Be careful about what you sign. Don't sign releases or accept billing write-offs that include waiver language until you understand what you're giving up.
Legal Support After a Surgical Error
A surgical error can leave you with more surgery, lost income, and lasting pain, along with a hospital that may not give you a clear explanation. Washington law gives you a path to accountability, but it comes with strict deadlines, procedural requirements, and a high standard of proof. At Lake Union Law Group PLLC, I review surgical injury cases with qualified medical reviewers to determine whether what happened was a known risk or a preventable mistake.
If you believe a surgical error harmed you or someone you love, contact me today to schedule a free consultation. I'll review your records, explain your options, and help you understand whether you have a claim before any deadline passes.